The Voice of the eCommerce Industry

Can ICANN Really Do Alchemy?

Media reports might have you believe that ICANN has discovered how to turn lead into gold, with their decision to create lots of new top-level domains (TLDs) for the Internet. But there could be a lot of fool's gold in the ICANN treasure chest, based on concerns and questions I heard at their meeting in Paris last week:

1. Some businesses advocating new TLDs claim they will help to categorize the web, much like bookstores arrange shelves by subject matter. For example, the applicants for a .berlin TLD claim it will help users find websites relating to Berlin. But I have to wonder how that's more useful than using 'berlin' in a conventional web search? The big winner in having millions of new domains is the big search engine that can sort it all out for us.
2. ICANN will entertain objections "relating to morality and public order" regarding the words or phrases proposed for new TLDs. Sounds like a responsible policy, but will paranoid governments use this policy to oppose new TLDs like .freedom or .democracy?
3. If a new TLD would create confusion with existing or similar TLDs, ICANN may deny the application. "Confusingly similar" is a good concept, but isn't something this subjective certain to generate controversy and litigation?
4. ICANN will have to pick winners and losers when multiple contenders want the same TLD. For example, who gets the .apple TLD – Apple computer, Apple records, or the Washington State Apple Growers Co-op?
5. Consumers and brand owners are rightly concerned about fraud and cyber-squatting in new TLDs. Is every new TLD going to generate a gold rush for domains that can be re-sold to global brand owners? Worse still, are cyber criminals going to exploit new TLDs to dupe users into revealing personal data or lure them into online scams?

Applicants for new TLDs will have to run a veritable gauntlet of objections and contentions, which could take many months or even years to complete. At the same time, ICANN doesn't want to keep restive governments waiting on domains that use non-Latin scripts, such as an Arabic and Chinese. So ICANN also approved a fast-track for governments to get country-code domains using non-Latin scripts, but users will be frustrated if this fast-track excludes the global TLDs (.com, .org, .edu ) they're really looking for.

These are legitimate questions and real concerns that ICANN must overcome to launch hundreds of new TLDs. I can already hear critics claiming that ICANN processes are delaying new TLDs and the resulting gold rush for millions of new domains.

Before ICANN and domain speculators catch gold fever over the promise of newly-minted TLDs, they ought to heed an old proverb – all that glitters is not gold.

Posted by Steve DelBianco

Top Stories

China is aggressively honing its ability to shoot down satellites, forcing the U.S. military to paint China as posing a growing threat to the United States and others in space and cyberspace.

Egypt will host the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers' (ICANN) 33rd International Public Meeting in November, after Kenya lost the bid on security grounds.

Top Stories

Col. Charles W. Williamson III is proposing that the Air Force build its own zombie network, so it can launch distributed denial of service attacks on foreign enemies.

The board of ICANN will vote in Paris next month on a proposal to severely limit the number of domain names that can be returned without a fee.

In Case You Missed It...

Big businesses need to start planning now to handle changes that will take place when a new version of the Internet's fundamental routing protocol becomes ubiquitous, or risk losing online customers, according to ICANN.

A hacker broke into Chile's government sites mining personal data from six million people which they then posted on two popular servers on the Internet.

Amazon.com has been operating a distribution center in Irving, TX since 2006, giving it a "physical presence" in Texas. The Texas Comptroller's Office is investigating whether the Internet retail behemoth, owes Texas possibly millions of dollars in uncollected internet sales taxes on purchases made by its customers in the state.

Florida Attorney General announced a nationwide partnership requires Facebook to digitally screen profiles, eliminating convicted sex offenders. It also checks that subscriber profiles match personal information, as well as an automatic "pop-up" warning will appear when youngsters try to contact adults.

ICANN chief says business leaders are grossly underestimating their firms' reliance on the internet and the risks of web-based threats.

Wholesale fees for Internet addresses ending in ".org" will increase 10 percent Nov. 9.

Two senior House Judiciary Committee members introduced a bill Thursday that could subject cable and telephone companies to antitrust enforcement if they unfairly handle Internet traffic.

Madonna has become the first artist to officially endorse the secondary ticket market.

Top Stories

There have been a number of suggested changes to ICANN's whois framework, but Canadian Internet Registration Authority (CIRA) is making changes to its .ca country code on its own.

A House subcommittee will examine proposed legislation that would make the principle of treating all Internet traffic equally into law.

Top Stories

A denial-of-service attack against Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty Web sites continues, with the broadcaster suggesting it could be the work of the Belarus government.

For years, domain squatters have exploited an ICANN loophole: whenever a domain name is registered, ICANN collects a 20-cent fee from the registrar. On April 17 ICANN's Generic Names Supporting Organization voted to make the 20-cent fee non-refundable. 

In Case You Missed It...

Maryland leaders capped off a whirlwind legislative session yesterday, signing into law the legislation that repealed Maryland's new computer services tax.

The Georgia Emergency Management Agency offered internet safety classes to parents to teach them how to protect their children from sexual predators and other Web dangers.

The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) announced that it posted the schedule for its public Meeting to be held in Paris June 22-26, 2008.

Portland State students and faculty are the latest to be hit by phishers claiming to be from User Support Services and other IT departments within the university. The scammers, dubbed "spear-phishers," try to gain user's confidence by posing as trusted individuals within an organization. 

In the News...

A number of ICANN (Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) working groups are attempting to debut internationalized domain names (IDNs) by early 2009, following the formulation of policies to better manage ambiguities.

According to the most recent survey of more than 125 retailers, U.S.consumers will spend $204 billion on online spending in 2008, a 17% increase from 2007.

Data exposure grows more frightening as the amount of malicious software released in the second half of 2007 outpaced the release of legitimate software. Symantec CEO called for the federal government to pass legislation governing data breach notification and standards on how to handle and report an exposure of customer or proprietary data.

Illinois and Texas both have laws on the books relating to Internet safety courses to be taught in public schools, but Virginia is currently the only state to require such courses.

Ticket Master and StubHub dominated the primary and secondary ticket market last month.

Top Stories

Human rights and pro-democracy groups sympathetic to anti-China demonstrators in Tibet are being targeted by cyber attacks, with organization receiving on average 20 e-mail virus attacks daily. The attacks are designed to disrupt their work and steal information on their members and activities.

The Executive Committee of the ICANN  Board agreed to grant a month long extension to the public comment period on the GNSO Improvements Report, and will now close on April 25, 2008.

Lawmakers locked in the crosshairs of repeal on the issue of tax on computer services in Maryland. The larger issue is if the bill is repealed, how they will replace the estimated $200 million that the tax would create if it goes into effect in July.

In Case You Missed It...

ICANN reportedly proposed a new policy that could stop individuals from domain name tasting by changing the refund process. Currently, domain name buyers have a 5 day grace period with a full refund which enables dishonest operators to test domains to see if they produce more in advertising profits than the cost of their registration for a year.

The Associated Press reports the military is increasing efforts to gather intelligence, fend off cyber-attacks and improve relations with other nations as part of a strategy for keeping the U.S. safe.

Facebook plans to roll out new privacy features that will give users more control over who sees the data stored on their profile pages.

Delegate LeRoy E. Myers Jr (R-Washington/Allegany) introduced a bill to the House on Tuesday that would make it a crime to steal wireless access in MD. According to the bill, unauthorized access to another person's computer, network, database or software is a misdemeanor.